Back to Contents

Environmental 
News and Action
Thank You Fay Sutton
Review of ski resorts
Insurance for clearing
Mt Ku-ring-gai fire
Silicon smelter update
New native vegetation coordinator

Thank You Fay Sutton

Conservationist

(24/6/1926 - 3/6/2000)

The finiteness of living things was brought home to environmentalists on hearing of the sudden death of Fay Sutton on 3 June 2000. Fay’s commitment to nature conservation and environmental protection over a period of more than 25 years gave an aura of permanence to the organisations and issues that she supported and promoted that we should not take for granted.


Over those years, Fay Sutton was involved in a wide diversity of environmental issues despite the physical limitations imposed by life in a wheelchair. Fay became a Councillor of the Australian Conservation Foundation in 1979 and joined the Executive of the Nature Conservation Council (NCC) in 1980, and retained both positions by election until her death.

During her time with the NCC, Fay represented the Council on a number of government committees dealing with issues such as bushfire management, Crown lands, Botany Bay, catchment management and the operations of the Land and Environment Court.

Fay was also active in a wide range of NCC’s internal committees including sustainable agriculture, bushfire management, publications and the Urban Bushland Sub-Committee, of which she was a member from its inception in the early 1980s. In addition, Fay came to exercise "grammatical" control over NCC’s conference publications, annual conference resolutions and Executive minutes, thus providing an important element of quality control.

During the 1990s Fay was the convenor for the NCC’s annual conferences, but her outstanding contribution was her almost single-handed development of the 1999 NCC Conference on the NSW Land and Environment Court. This conference has led to an official review process and Fay was very excited to be convening an NCC workshop on the review at Parliament House. The highly successful workshop was held on 23 June as planned – thank you Fay!

Fay will be remembered for her remorseless commitment to grammatical correctness; her feisty way of dealing with policy conflicts; her scientific rigour in relation to policy development; and for her enduring commitment to the need to drive the search for ecological sustainability. But most of all for her gutsy cheerfulness that covered a strong will to overcome her physical limitations in the cause of conserving nature for both its intrinsic values and for the benefit of present and future generations.

Judy Messer
Chairperson
Nature Conservation Council of NSW

Review of ski resorts

The Coronial Inquiry into the Thredbo landslide has blamed this disaster on the Roads and Traffic Authority and the National Parks and Wildlife Service, leading the NSW Government to announce an inquiry into the Service’s management of the national park’s roads and ski resorts.

The tragic events at Thredbo did involve a road (the Alpine Way), and a ski resort, but it is questionable whether this can justify – as some are suggesting – stripping the NPWS of its powers to control park roads and resorts.

Few would suggest that Perisher and Smiggins Holes are vulnerable in the same way as Thredbo: these ski resorts have a different topography and do not present the same instability and safety issues.

The pervasive issue in managing roads and ski resorts in Kosciuszko National Park is finding a balance between the demands of the skiing industry and protecting the national park environment. The industry wants to compete with ski resorts in Victoria and New Zealand which do not operate within national parks, and apparently do not have to tiptoe around such a variety of threatened species habitats. The NPWS already has many problems protecting Kosciuszko NP and its wildlife and, without the power to control road and resort development, may find this impossible.

To excise the roads and resorts from the park would seriously undermine the NPWS as the park manager. A halfway position which vests development control in the local council or some other authority would be no better. If the Government wants to improve the situation, it should provide the NPWS with a proper charter for managing the ski resorts and the capacity to administer it.

It is revealing that the ski resorts are now being described in Government statements as ‘urban areas’ . Perhaps this describes the future intended for them.

Peter Prineas
Nature Conservation Council

Insurance for clearing

Insurance giant, AMP, has come under fire from Queensland conservation groups. AMP subsidiary, Stanbroke Pastoral Company, has applied to clear more land than any other landowner in Queensland. AMP claims that much of the clearing is simply sound management to remove regrowth which is impeding pasture productivity. Nevertheless, these areas are important for biodiversity, and it does not say much for an insurance company to be a major contributor to global warming through land clearing. The protests against AMP have targeted the company’s role as an Olympic sponsor, and have seen people arrested in Brisbane.

NPA members should consider whether AMP is a suitable company to do business with. It is hard to reconcile their land clearing with an ethical approach to business.

Mt Ku-ring-gai fire

Three NPWS workers were killed and another four seriously injured in June when a hazard reduction burning operation turned horribly wrong. The three dead workers were Claire Deane, Eric Furlan and George Fitzsimmons. Those injured were Jamie Shaw, Mark Cupit, Natalie Saville and Luke McSweeney. NPA expresses its condolences to the families of all seven victims, and hope and support for those recovering from their injuries. NPWS staff often work in hazardous situations and their efforts in protecting our valuable natural areas are recognised by all at NPA.

A thanksgiving memorial service held in recognition of all seven people was attended by NPA President, Roger Lembit, and Vice-Presidents, Anne Reeves and Stephen Lord.

Roger Lembit

Silicon smelter update

The threat to western woodlands from the proposed Gunnedah charcoal plant remains serious (to supply the proposed Lithgow silicon smelter – see previous Journals). Supported by NPA, local opposition is expanding, with Gunnedah Environment Group, Tamworth Environment Group, North-east Forest Alliance and the North East Environment Council now joining the campaign.

The yearly volume of hardwood to be consumed has been increased from 160,000 tonnes to 230,000 tonnes, to compensate for the use of lower density timbers now that Pilliga and Goonoo are unavailable. More than 40 huge trucks each day will carry ‘residue’ wood to Gunnedah from State forests and sawmills to the east, as well as timber from landholders willing to sell the few remaining trees in the region.

In breach of the Premier’s announcement, it appears that Pilliga, 35 km to the west, would become available for the smelter after a forest assessment is complete.

In July the Department of Urban Affairs and Planning (DUAP) released a CSIRO report which investigated non-wood alternatives in silicon production. It was found that alternatives do exist and should be investigated further. These include Ultra-Clean Coal and briquetted hardwood sourced from sawmills or second-hand timber. Softwoods and coal could also possibly be used. The report emphasised that old growth hardwood trees are ideal, reminding us that the 100+ year-old ironbark, box, stringybark and red gum woodlands will not be secure with a charcoal plant at Gunnedah.

DUAP’s Assessments Branch has played a positive role in seeking to reduce environmental impacts of the silicon smelter; for instance, they took up NPA's suggestion to seek advice from CSIRO. It has been the planning laws that have allowed for the failure to look at the entire development proposal – from the sourcing of raw materials to their distribution as end products, and all the steps in between.

Andrew Cox
Western Woodland Project Officer

New native vegetation coordinator

Paul Kravchenko has replaced Peter Wright (a name familiar to many Journal readers) as the Nature Conservation Council of NSW’s Native Vegetation Coordinator. Paul was previously working for the NCC as the Urban Bushland Project Officer, and has come to the new position with a firm belief in the need for regional planning and a strong legislative framework for conserving native vegetation. He has been active in environmental issues in western Sydney for many years.

Some of the issues Paul is encountering are: the removal of woodland remnants for private plantations; unsustainable private native forest activities; and the lack of an effective incentive framework for private landholders to conserve vegetation.

Paul Kravchenko
Nature Conservation Council


 National Parks Association - Home Page
 
Other editions of the National Parks Journal
 

Top of page